This is a great question and I found an answer! Personal finance blogger, Jim, from Bargaineering.com posted a video of his thoughts about when to repair something that is broken and when to just replace it.
Here is the link to his video.
This is a great topic that I’ve been thinking about lately because I recently ‘lost’ a key component to my kitchen hand mixer, the beater. There were two beaters and now there is one.
And when I say ‘lost’ I mean that I accidentally threw it in the trash. Oops!
It’s just one of those things. You know, one of those hectic times that you’re doing 12 things at once (including licking the cake batter off the beater) and you aren’t really thinking straight. I’m sure I went to throw something away and the beater just happened to be in my hand.
There is no evidence that this actually happened, but after checking every single nook and cranny in my kitchen, and every other room for that matter, it’s just not there.
So, I’ve been asking the question, do I buy a new mixer or do I try to find another beater and just ‘fix’ the old one? I was thinking that it would be cheaper to just buy a replacement beater and get on with my cake baking life. So, I did a little research.

I looked up the hand mixer online and found the exact product name and number. Then I looked up replacement beaters for this specific mixer. Turns out, they only come in pairs, so I would have to buy two beaters for the low, sale price of $17.95.
Um, excuse me, did I miss something? Why is the replacement beater exactly $10 less than the price of the ENTIRE hand mixer??
So, you’re saying that if I just shell out another $10, I could get a brand new mixer?!
I think that is totally worth it. If I pay the $17.95, I’m getting an extra beater that I don’t need and I still have an old hand mixer. This is definitely one of those times where it is better to replace than to repair.
And I could probably sell the old hand mixer minus a beater at a yard sale for a few bucks. Anyone looking for a used hand mixer with a (very important) part missing?
Check out Jim’s thoughts here.